We are completely out of those sticky eye patches (and Matt just pulls them off anyways). I found a great tutorial on Lucy Kate Crafts so I could make my own felt eye patches.
Matt doesn't mind wearing these. In fact, he often wears them for more than the prescribed time because he is not complaining about them, and we forget he is wearing them.
Of course, it does help that his favorite patch (not pictured here) was made to look like a pirate patch (i.e. skull and crossbones) and he wants to BE a pirate.